5.0 (1542 reviews)

4.5 Star Rating Is Better Than 5 Star Rating

star rating

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

While a perfect 5-star rating may seem like the ultimate level of customer satisfaction, a 4.5-star rating has some advantages that make it preferable occasionally. With a 4.5 rating, you can see excellent customer satisfaction and a few drawbacks. A 4.5-star ranking represents near perfection in terms of customer satisfaction. A rating of 5 stars may suggest that reviews have been manipulated. But a rating of 4 stars seems more accurate because it leaves an opportunity for improvement and shows that the company is constantly working to improve things.

Some clients value constructive feedback while making decisions and appreciate a balanced review strategy. Do not be deceived by a perfect score; instead, continue reading as we explain how a slightly lower rating could reveal the genuineness of a company that results in customer satisfaction. 

What Is a Star Rating System?

The Google star rating system is a highly regarded means for assessing and communicating how well-made a product or satisfying an experience is. The most typical rating scheme is a five-point scale, with one star indicating the lowest and five stars corresponding to the highest. Star ratings serve as a sign of quality. It is often used in various sectors, including customer ratings, hospitality, ecommerce, and entertainment. They are used in many countries and reflect the client’s experience in terms of quality and overall condition. 

Image Source

Why a Rating of 4.5 Stars Is Appropriate

According to a study by Northwestern, consumers are more inclined to purchase an item from a brand with a rating of 4.2 and 4.5 stars out of a perfect 5-star rating. Despite being counterintuitive, negative feedback may help develop credibility. Consumers value negative feedback because it helps them make informed choices.

Because a perfect 5-star review reflects the highest level of satisfaction, it is customarily preferred above a 4.5-star rating. A business that receives a five-star rating is regarded as outstanding, has little to no potential for development, and receives the greatest recognition. 

In some circumstances, a 4.5 rating could be preferable or more reliable for the following reasons:

  • Various Expectations

Different people have different expectations and opinions. A 4.5-star rating may indicate that, while most shoppers enjoy the product or service, it may not be the best option for everyone. Factors like the nature of the service or product, price point, brand reputation, target market, and personal preferences give potential customers a more detailed understanding of what to anticipate.

  • Genuineness

Customers may be suspicious of goods or services with 5-star ratings as they may seem too good to be true. They may doubt the company’s customer reviews have been fabricated or manipulated. A 4.5 rating with helpful criticism can be more sincere and reliable. Also, you may check if the reviews came from verified consumers who purchased goods or services from a business. These online reviews are more likely to be genuine and leave real feedback on review sites.

  • Limited Number of Reviews

Sometimes only a few reviews contribute to a rating of 4.5, and a single negative review could greatly impact the average. The rating may reflect how people feel more accurately as the number of reviews increases. The rating would be more trustworthy if the company had more reviews overall. A 4.5-star rating is more likely to reflect customer satisfaction when there are many reviews accurately. 

  • Modest Progress

A company or service provider with a 4.5 rating may be considered one who consistently strives for improvement and values customer feedback. This mindset is upbeat and client-focused. To provide customers with a better experience, honest progress means that the rating reflects genuine customer feedback. A 4.5-star rating indicates that the business cares about exceeding customers’ expectations when it shows a customer-focused approach.

Significant Insights for Business Owners

Encourage Customers to Leave a Review

As an enterprise, you should do more than ask for feedback from satisfied consumers. It has the potential to significantly affect the outcome of your business. Effective feedback collection can result from customer engagement, service enhancements, and revenue gains. The strengths and weaknesses of your company can be discovered from customers leaving reviews. 

You may learn more about what customers like and don’t like about your product or service by asking them to post reviews. Increase your company’s credibility and trustworthiness with positive reviews. High ratings influence the decision-making of potential buyers who frequently seek reassurance from those who have used your product or service. A collection of good testimonials can win over customers hesitating about purchasing from your company. Real reviews from happy consumers say a lot about what you offer and provide a positive impact on your business.

Examine Your Review Statistics

Strategic decisions, enhanced customer experiences, and overall business performance can all be due to insights from analyzing review data. Studying your review data might help you learn more about your customers’ interests and perspectives. You can learn about patterns and consumer concerns by analyzing the details of your services and goods mentioned often in reviews. These insights provide an approach for improving your offers to align with customer expectations, whether the commendation is for outstanding customer service, complimentary product features, or areas requiring development.

Don’t Use Fake Reviews

The reputation of a company can be damaged if its reviews are fake. Customers are getting better at spotting fraudulent feedback, and it only takes one fake review to make people suspicious of the rest. Once a customer’s trust has been broken, getting them back is sometimes impossible. Furthermore, dishonesty and transparency are compromised when false reviews are used. Companies have a responsibility to provide honest descriptions of their offers.

Neglecting these ideals through deceitful behavior can have serious professional and legal consequences. Fraudulent reviews can interfere with customers’ legitimate comments. Businesses miss out on genuine feedback that may help them improve their goods and services and the consumer experience when they instead flood review platforms with fake compliments. Consumers’ feedback is priceless in identifying improvement opportunities and maintaining a competitive edge.

Appreciate Constructive Reviews

Getting critical feedback might help you see where your company can improve. They provide an additional viewpoint from the customer’s perspective, allowing organizations to see things they might have missed. An approach that shows appreciation for these is more sophisticated and customer-focused since it shows a willingness to listen, learn, and develop. It helps you learn more about your customers and what they want.

By reading and responding to customer feedback, companies can learn more about what matters most to their customer base. They can then adjust what they provide to reasonably meet the demands of their customers, resulting in higher levels of satisfaction and loyalty. It also demonstrates enthusiasm is more promising. This exemplifies the company’s dedication to continuously improving its products and services to provide consumers with the greatest possible experiences. It also sends a message to customers that their feedback is being heard and considered.


PowerReviews is a software company that provides solutions for online retailers based on consumer feedback. They offer a comprehensive platform for businesses to gather and manage customer ratings, comments, and reviews to boost sales and customer loyalty. PowerReviews is a helpful tool that helps shoppers make informed decisions. Before making a purchase, consumers may read reviews written by actual buyers, view ratings, and learn more about a product’s features. Badges showing that a buyer has been verified give legitimacy to customer feedback and other user-generated content.

In addition, it provides statistics and insights to help companies better comprehend customer feedback. Their reporting functions facilitate data-driven decision-making by allowing businesses to identify patterns, strengths, and weaknesses. Their combination improves consumers’ confidence in the company and their buying experience. PowerReviews is a crucial tool for helping companies harness the value of consumer reviews. With their help, businesses may use honest client feedback to increase revenue, strengthen customer relationships, and improve their offer. They serve businesses and customers with innovative methods for collecting and analyzing customer feedback.

Image Source

Frequently Asked Questions

What Does a Rating of 4.5 Star Mean?

A rating of 4.5 stars on a business page indicates that the product or service is above average and well-liked by those who have tried it. While it does not receive a perfect score, it is regarded as having exceptional quality with only minor drawbacks. Given that it is half-star short of the maximum score of 5, the products or services offered are a solid option for prospective consumers. It serves as obvious proof that they deserve consideration. To make an informed choice, it is vital to read consumers’ reviews and consider personal preferences and needs, just like with any rating.

Is 4.5 Stars on Google a Decent Rating?

A business with acceptable ratings and reviews is one with 4.5 stars. It means most users or consumers who have provided the products, services, or experience have positive customer feedback. It is a reliable sign of good merchandise or service.
Having a 4.5-star rating on Google says a lot about the reliability and standards of a company. It indicates that the company cares about its clients and wants to continue making them delighted. 

Is a 3-Star Rating Good in Business?

A rating of 3 stars is regarded as an average star rating. It implies that the customer’s experience could have been better and that the company satisfies the basic requirements and has some strengths, but there is still room for improvement. There may need to be more than a three-star rating in highly competitive sectors, as consumers have high standards and often seek elsewhere. The value of a 3-star rating is proportional to the number of reviews it has received. If there are many five-star reviews, one less-than-perfect review may matter less to potential customers. However, concerns might be raised if a company frequently earns 3-star ratings or more negative reviews than positive reviews.


It is significant to remember that these views might differ and that how star ratings are interpreted depends entirely on personal preferences and the situation in which they are utilized. Whether a product, service, or customer experience deserves the best star rating of 5 or 4.5-star rating will rely on how well it meets the needs and expectations of potential customers.

Joe Troyer

Joe Troyer is the Founder of Review Grower. He is leading expert in all things Internet Marketing: Pay Per Click Marketing, Search Engine Optimization, Google Business, Reputation Management, Landing Page Conversion, and Call Tracking.

More from Joe Troyer

Related Blogs

Industry Specific

In the fast-evolving world of car dealerships, online reviews have become an invaluable tool for potential buyers. Whether you’re looking to purchase a new vehicle


Patients often discover about you online first in this digital age through medical review websites. A good online presence on several review sites is one

Industry Specific

Understanding the importance of customer feedback as a retail brand can significantly impact your market performance. Major customer review sites play a significant role in

Enter Your Email To Request A Personalized Demo

Group ()
Trusted By 1500+ People

By submitting your contact info, you authorize Reviewgrower to message you to schedule a demo and setup your account via email and/or sms as well as send promotional offers.

Your Complete Solution for Building an Online Presence.

image ()
image ()
image ()
image ()
image ()
image ()