5.0 (1542 reviews)

Debunking the Myth: Separating Fact from Fiction in Online Review Bias

online review bias

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

When making decisions about buying goods or services, online reviews have become crucial because they give us important information about other customers’ experiences, which we may use to make wise judgments.

Online review bias is the propensity of certain reviewers to post comments that are not typical of their overall experiences. Extreme sentiments, limited memories, or a lack of drive to leave feedback are just a few causes of this bias. So, to make better selections based on trustworthy and accurate information in this situation, it is essential to grasp all kinds of web review biases and how to spot them.

What Is It?

The tendency of online reviews to be biased in favor of or against a service or product is called online review bias. It is accepted that internet review systems are frequently skewed, severely hurting the efficiency of information sharing among consumers.

How do I Identify It?

It can be detected in several ways; for example, one of them is to verify the review’s profile and scan the review for specifics. Another method is to keep an eye out for brand mentions that are repeated and to read the online product review carefully, and black-and-white reviews that lean too much toward the good or the negative should also be avoided.

It might be challenging to spot bias in internet reviews, but there are a few factors to keep in mind.

  • Keep an eye out for extreme reviews; if you notice a lot of reviews that are either very positive or very negative, this can indicate bias. A high number of excessively positive or negative reviews may be cause for concern because it’s uncommon for every single consumer to have an amazing experience with a service or product.
  • Verify the terminology used; watch out for extreme evaluations that are dramatic or emotional, as this may indicate prejudice, a review that states it may be displaying strong bias.
  • Look for partners; if you see that a specific feature of a good or service is constantly being complimented or condemned in several reviews, this can indicate bias; for instance, bias may be evident if numerous reviews complain about poor customer service without providing other information about the reviewers’ experience.

Why Are Reviews Important?

Because they are an effective method for disseminating knowledge widely, it is crucial keeping in mind the source: many modern online reviews come from people who have freely chosen to offer their ideas, providing a skewed image of goods, services, and businesses.

Online platforms may significantly lessen bias while encouraging fewer extremist voices to participate in the online discourse by using reasonably priced incentives, as demonstrated in this case. Online reviews are, at their core, social activities, reminding people of the benefits of sharing their ideas online can have a significant effect on their readiness to do so, and increase the value of today’s pervasive online review platforms.

Furthermore, they play a crucial role in how well firms perform in searches. Additionally, companies with higher star ratings find gains in sales as well as better consumer loyalty and trust, you should look for and use a review management tool to make sure your company does not fall behind and that you are getting the most out of your online reputation.

About Bias in Online Reviews

Image source

Social Influence Bias

It happens when a user’s opinion is affected by another people’s opinion; for example, when you read other people’s evaluations, you are unconsciously far more likely to form a consensus viewpoint, and if you publish a review, it is a lot more likely to match the sentiment of the other reviewers.

Therefore, customers who leave reviews are more inclined to copy other customers and leave negative reviews of your business. Individuals are inclined to leave positive reviews if your company has received positive feedback.

Selection Bias

When a reviewer’s sample does not accurately reflect the buying public as a whole. The undercover is the name given to selection bias’s initial factor; for example, when only a petite portion of your clients have left reviews, and the reviewers are not typical of your larger consumer base, this is the case.

Voluntary response bias is the second aspect of selection bias. In simple terms, the people who submit reviews do so for several reasons, which frequently results in an overrepresentation of people with strong opinions in the sample.

The online reviewers are not typical of your wider customer base because it is quite likely that they are made up of one side exceptionally satisfied consumers and other extremely dissatisfied consumers, which segments only make up a tiny fraction of your overall customer base.

Confirmation Bias

When a person searches for and analyzes information (such as news articles, statistical data, or other people’s opinions) that confirms an existing premise or idea if someone already is convinced that gender bias does not exist and you offer them concrete proof to the contrary, they are considerably more likely to reject the data than to change their mind.

Here are some features; a refusal to recognize the truth of data that contradict one’s preexisting views, giving more weight or importance to facts that support the person’s presumptions at the expense of contrary evidence, and actively looking for data to support the person’s position; and selective recall of facts, events, or figures.

Bias and Inaccuracy

Lack of Standardization

A well-designed mass study will make a significant effort to standardize replies since ambiguous or contradictory response criteria will render an otherwise valid survey invalid. Review sites benefit from a single, standardized format (grading items from 1 to 5 stars), but the requirements for those scores vary greatly depending on the customer review.

Varying Expectations

Unrealistic client expectations put the company up for failure, and frequently, the manager’s ability to establish and oversee customer expectations can have a greater impact on the review score of the company than the service quality. Suppose a particular client has a distinct set of expectations from another. In that case, the reviews are likely to be distinct, even if the same technician conducts the same service on a similar vehicle for the same customer.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Your review scores do not matter alone, users take note of the volume, regularity, freshness, and substance of the reviews you provide on the internet. Smaller companies have an intrinsic disadvantage if we focus on the volume of evaluations.

If all the other factors (such as closeness, products offered, review score, etc.) are held constant, customers will typically select the vendor with the most reviews.

Industry Bias

Customers are inclined to give online ratings to companies in specific industries. Additionally, online customers are considerably more inclined to provide a review for a service (such as a restaurant, hotel, vacation site, spa, or personal care facility) if they link it to their satisfaction. Probably, you have fewer reviews if you own a gym, real estate agency, dental office, or wrecking yard.

Because enterprises operating in a single market will all compete fairly, if one of your rivals provides services across different businesses and functions, it could become an issue.

How Can Companies Combat Review Bias?

Image source 

Businesses must implement processes that raise the caliber of their customers’ review data, lowering comment bias and the possibility of review manipulation online. 

Actively Request Feedback

Promoting as many genuine good ratings as you can is one strategy to lessen comment prejudice and promote balanced review sentiment. It works well in the first phases of the rating process. 

When requesting reviews, there are many alternatives. You can send texts and email requests, use a client’s feedback system, distribute surveys, or make feedback demand handouts that are distributed following client transactions.

Remind Clients That Their Feedback Benefits Others

When people are informed that leaving online evaluations benefits other people, they are more inclined to do so. Simple beneficial incentives also reduced the bias in the distribution of reviews, resulting in a bell-curve dispersion of reviews that is more typical.

Provide Incentives to Motivate People

Reviews can be encouraged without necessarily being compensated with money, gifts, or discounts. Non-monetary incentives for businesses based on the tenet of give-to-get can encourage less outspoken middle-of-the-road clients to post their comments online.

In return for free access to handy information on its website, an employer reviews website-requested content from its users. 

The rule made it possible for more users to submit reviews to the website. Additionally, it has been producing an illustration of the dispersion of internet opinions regarding certain goods, services, and businesses that were more fair and accurate.

What About Negative Reviews?

Image source

The investigation of the negativity bias in the influence of the valence of the content of online reviews on consumers’ attitudes focuses on the context of online services and draws on an adaptation view of negative information, showing that it could be assigned to the higher-viewed diagnostician of negative reviews. Are decided by consumers’ in-depth explanations of reviews’ contents, which depend on their prior knowledge of the internet service industry and cognitive requirements.


Are Reviews Found Online Reliable?

An investigation indicated that some reviews might be deliberately biased or only manipulated. Sociological proof, a psychological and sociological occurrence where people assume the acts of others reflect appropriate behavior in a specific setting, is one of the main reasons for contributing to online review bias. For this reason, you must be careful and have your criteria set so as not to be fooled by any review you see on the Internet.

Why Are Negative Reviews Biased?

It is when a cognitive bias known as the negativity bias causes negative occurrences to have a greater psychological impact than happy ones. Even when negative and positive occurrences are of equal size, negativity bias still exists, making us more sensitive to negative events.

What Is the Relationship Between Social Proof and Biased Reviews?

A psychological bias that is strongly ingrained produces social proof. It suggests faith in other people. The different kinds of this confidence include the conviction that the majority is correct and that it is always wise to consider the choices made by others when coming to a decision.


In summary, online review bias is a nuanced phenomenon that has the potential to significantly influence how we make decisions. While we depend on online reviews to help us make buying choices, we should also be conscious of the possibility of bias and read them critically.

The platforms that post these evaluations could also be part of the prejudice, so it’s not only the reviewers who are to blame. For instance, certain platforms might give some reviews more weight than others or offer incentives to reviewers who provide favorable comments.

We must try to develop more transparent and equitable review platforms that take into account the variety of experiences to prevent prejudice in online reviews. In the end, we may make more informed judgments and be sure that the goals are in line with reality by being conscious of online review bias and adopting a more critical mindset.

Alex Contes

My past experience is as a Senior Full Stack Developer/Tech Lead. I have 16+ years of experience working in web development. Now I’ve transitioned to a SaaS product owner. Successfully launched my first product ReviewGrower as a Co-Founder after working on it for almost two years.

More from Alex Contes

Related Blogs

Industry Specific

Many banks focus their attention on landing new clients with small cash bonuses or higher interest rates on savings accounts, but they’re missing out on

Industry Specific

Are you an optometrist looking for effective ways to market your practice? This article will explore various optometry marketing ideas that will help you attract

Industry Specific

With more than 490 million monthly active users and millions of listings for lodging, dining, attractions, and experiences, Tripadvisor is the largest travel information website

Enter Your Email To Request A Personalized Demo

Group ()
Trusted By 1500+ People

By submitting your contact info, you authorize Reviewgrower to message you to schedule a demo and setup your account via email and/or sms as well as send promotional offers.

Your Complete Solution for Building an Online Presence.

image ()
image ()
image ()
image ()
image ()
image ()